And now, the conclusion. This is the second part of the only two-part episode of the original series. You can read part 1 here. While I nitpicked a lot for part 1, there’s actually not much for part 2. Let’s find out what I thought!
Season 1, Episode 11: The Menagerie: Part 1
Original Air Date: November 24, 1966
Planet: Talos IV
Featured Alien: Talosians
Main Cast: Kirk, Spock
Main Guest Characters: Captain Christopher Pike (Jeffrey Hunter), Commodore Jose I. Mendez (Malachi Throne), Fleet Captain Pike (Sean Kenney), Lt. Piper (Julie Parrish), Lt. Hansen (Hagan Beggs), Number One (Majel Barrett), Dr. Philip Boyce (John Hoyt), Vina (Susan Oliver), The Keeper (Meg Wyllie), Yeoman J. M. Colt (Laurel Goodwin)
Things I Noticed
Pike said the Enterprise was from a stellar group from the other end of the galaxy. We now know that’s not going to be true according to later Star Trek series. For one thing, Talos IV isn’t that far from Starbase 11. And being only 100 years after the founding of the Federation, the explored part of the galaxy is quite small. Talos IV isn’t that far from Earth.
When the Talosians communicate telepathically, the veins on their heads pulsate. Weird.
The creatures on Rigel VII are humanoid, wear clothes, and seem to live in a medieval-like society, so why do they roar like animals rather than speak?
Number One has blue nail polish. She can wear it. It’s just that it was interesting to notice.
The pilot episode was the first time we saw Orion slave girls.
The image shown on the screen during the trial is washed out. You’d think they’d have better video equipment.
They have lasers, not phasers. Even in the time of Captain Archer, they had phase pistols (phasers).
At the end of “The Cage,” they said hyperdrive, not warp drive. Of course, at this time, they hadn’t established the technology of Star Trek.
There’s not really much I can add about this episode that I haven’t already said about Part 1. The episode continues in much the same way, though this tends to be far more about “The Cage” than original footage. Even the main cast members have been reduced to only Kirk and Spock.
The acting by Shatner and Nimoy is still quite good. I really enjoyed the high quality of acting in this episode. No overacting, no awkwardness, no silliness. Just plain good acting.
The final scenes with the Talosians appear to also be from original footage of the pilot, though I don’t recall seeing them in the pilot.
Overall, I thought this pair of episodes was very well done, even though they were essentially clips episodes.
What did you think of the conclusion? And do you know if the final scenes with the Talosians are actually original footage from the pilot? I haven’t seen the original “The Cage” in quite some time. Should I review it? Let me know in the comments section below.